Category Archives: HOA Knowledge Base

Roberts Rules of Order

Most homeowners associations attempt to follow Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised (1990 Edition). However, in keeping with the modern times, many associations have adopted specific procedural rules to shorten the debate and make the orderly flow of the meeting less cumbersome. Here are some procedures to consider adopting that further clarify Robert’s Rules of Order.

Suggested Adaptations to Roberts Rules of Order:

Allow alternating debate on the issue. One speaker would present information in favor of the motion; then allow a presentation by a speaker opposed to the motion. When no one wishes to speak on a particular side, ask unanimous consent to end debate. “Is there any objection to closing discussion? Hearing no objection, discussion is closed.”

When seeking out discussion, encourage new discussion rather than permit repetition by the speakers.

Always provide an opportunity for those who have not spoken to address the motion on the floor.

On the agenda, record a start and end time for each discussion item. This will let speakers know in advance how much time is available.

Along those same lines, announce at the beginning of the meeting what time the meeting will adjourn. Board members often police themselves if they are aware of a deadline.

Ask for a motion to end discussion. (“Is there a motion to close debate?”).

If it is perceived that discussion on an issue may become quite lengthy, set a specific discussion time. (“Is there a motion to limit total debate to (20) minutes?”).

Establish speaking rules for all meetings:
Limit the speaker’s time to no more than (3) minutes.
Limit the speaker to one opportunity to verbalize on the issue.
Ask speakers to direct their comments to the chair.

© Association Times

Permission to reprint any of the information contained in this article is granted provided Association Times is credited as the source.


Consistency is the Key to Success

Perhaps the most frustrating thing for a customer is inconsistent service. McDonald’s prides itself on providing consistent products and service. When you eat at a McDonalds in Pittsburgh or Paris you know that your double cheeseburger will taste the same, be the same size and be served in the same packaging. There is comfort in knowing what to expect.

Customer service for Owners in a Community Association should be as reliable as McDonalds. Every caller should be treated with respect and a friendly and cooperative manner. Board members sometimes need to be reminded that personal differences with a neighbor should not affect the outcome of an architectural change request. Managers need to keep in mind that “even a broken clock is right twice a day”. They should listen to the frequent caller as they would a first-time caller. They should not assume they are wrong or just complaining…again.

Decisions based on personality or “who you know” are dangerous. If statues are not permitted in the front beds, don’t overlook the statue in front of a committee member’s home because “she does so much for the community”. You will have a difficult time defending and enforcing the rule elsewhere. Deviation from the adopted rules creates inconsistency that cannot be upheld.

The Board’s decision should be supported by the documents, current laws, best practices and opinions from their community manager, attorney, accountant, engineer and other professionals. Personal feelings should not enter into the discussion.

Owners should expect, and receive consistent treatment when they deal with any representative of the Association. Prompt and efficient responses to maintenance service requests, accounting questions or reports of violations should be routine. Committee and Board meetings should be scheduled to ensure reasonable response time to owner requests. Pushing a friend’s request through without the normal process will anger other Owners who have to wait for their decisions.

We know we will never please everyone but we can avoid appeals based upon the way they were treated rather than the decision that was made. The rules and architectural guidelines are in place to ensure a uniform appearance throughout the community. Don’t fall into the trap of straying from uniform enforcement. Inconsistent treatment of Owners opens the Association up to possible legal action and negative publicity for the community. The Board and management must do everything they can to create an atmosphere of community and fair treatment that will enhance the lifestyle of the Association.

Gail VanDyke, PCAM

Mid-Atlantic Management, Plymouth Meeting, PA

© Association Times
Permission to reprint any of the information contained in this article is granted provided Association Times is credited as the source.